Personality assessments have become increasingly common in pastoral candidate evaluation — and with good reason. Tools like the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, the Enneagram, DiSC, and 16Personalities offer genuine insight into how a person thinks, relates, leads, and handles stress. Used well, they add a valuable dimension to candidate evaluation. Used poorly, they become a substitute for judgment rather than a supplement to it.
What Personality Assessments Can Tell You
A well-administered personality assessment can surface information about a candidate's natural leadership style, his approach to conflict, his preference for structure or flexibility, his energy patterns in social environments, and his typical response to stress and pressure. This information helps a committee understand not just what a candidate has done but how he is wired to do it — and whether that wiring fits the context your church is offering him.
Navigating a pastor search?
Premier Church Staffing walks with churches through every phase. There is no cost to an initial conversation.
Schedule a free consultationWhat Personality Assessments Cannot Tell You
A personality assessment cannot tell you whether a candidate is called to ministry. It cannot measure his theological convictions, his integrity, his relational health, or his character under pressure. It cannot predict how he will handle a congregational crisis, a personal moral failure in his family, or a doctrinal dispute with a deacon. These are the things that most determine pastoral success — and they are not captured by any personality instrument.
How to Use Assessments Appropriately
Use personality assessments as one data point among many, not as a filter or a qualifier. A candidate who tests as an introvert is not disqualified from pastoral ministry — some of the most effective pastors in history have been deeply introverted. A candidate who tests as highly decisive is not guaranteed to be a strong leader — decisiveness without wisdom produces a different set of problems. Read assessment results with nuance and curiosity, not with rigid conclusions.
Discuss Results With the Candidate
The most valuable use of a personality assessment is as a conversation starter, not as a verdict. Share the results with the candidate and ask him to respond to them. Does he recognize himself in the profile? Where does he think the instrument got it right, and where does he think it missed? How has his personality type shaped his ministry positively, and where has it created challenges? A candidate who can reflect thoughtfully on his own personality and its effects is demonstrating the self-awareness that ministry requires.
Consider Context Fit, Not Just Profile
Different church contexts benefit from different leadership styles. A church that is navigating significant conflict may benefit from a pastor with high emotional stability and patience. A church that needs to establish a new vision may benefit from a pastor with strong initiative and communication gifts. Use personality assessment results to think about fit with your specific context — not to evaluate candidates against an abstract ideal.